Are Vitamins Bad For You?

by Dr. Daniel J. Heller December 17, 2013

Major media outlets like NPR, Fox News, the Wall Street Journal, and others are telling us that new studies published in the Annals of Internal Medicine have conclusively proven that vitamins and supplements are a waste of money at best, and possibly even bad for you.

This is a familiar refrain of these large media outlets and the medical commentariat. A couple of years ago, a very similar story prompted this same kind of hysteria from the same sources. In that case, we found that it was easy to poke holes in the conclusions that were being trumpeted as “airtight.” In that case, we enlisted the help of Nutritional Medicine Expert Dr. Alan R. Gaby to help us understand the merits of the 2011 studies, and their very obvious faults.

There are three new studies that have caused this new hue and cry. We’re going to examine them one by one, and see if they really do tell us that vitamins are worthless.

One of the studies looks at what happened when people took a multivitamin, or a placebo (sugar pill) after they’d had a heart attack. Although we’re not sure what multivitamin was used, most such studies use the equivalent of Centrum Silver®. The average age in the study was 65; 18% were women; and the average time between the first heart attack, and beginning a multivitamin, was 4.5 years.

The results of this study don’t apply to people under the age of 65, or to women, or to people who’ve never had a heart attack, or to people who start taking a multivitamin shortly after a first heart attack! Unfortunately, you don’t get that impression from the media reports and from the medical doctors commenting on the study. You get the impression that this study concluded that for everyone, multivitamins are unhealthy and a waste of money. However, the authors themselves didn’t find any negative effects of taking a multivitamin in this group of older men, nor do they try to say that their results apply to younger people who haven’t had a heart attack.

The next study compared a multivitamin to placebo for its effect on cognitive decline, such as memory loss and Alzheimers. This study was conducted on close to 6000 male doctors aged 65 or older. Again, these results are meaningless for women; for people under the age of 65, and even for people with very different levels of wealth and education, compared to American male doctors.

The last study was not original research but rather a study of studies to examine whether vitamins and minerals could help prevent cancer or heart disease in those who had never had those conditions. This type of study allowed the researchers to look at existing scientific evidence for multivitamins as well as individual nutrients such as vitamin E, selenium, folic acid, and calcium. The value of this kind of study is that it includes very large numbers of study subjects, so the authors are less likely to be fooled by random occurrences. However, the conclusions they were able to reach were limited because in each study, different preparations of different nutrients were used. The authors concluded that two good quality studies on multivitamins showed a slightly reduced incidence of cancer in men but not women, and confirmed what many other studies have found: that isolated Vitamin E and beta-carotene raise risks of disease.

The authors actually give a conditional endorsement to the concept of using multivitamins in their article:

“One explanation for this result (that studies on individual nutrients often don’t find the benefit that some would expect) could be that the physiologic systems affected by vitamins and other antioxidant supplements are so complex that the effects of supplementing with only 1 or 2 components is generally ineffective or actually does harm.”

The editorial accompanying the three studies proclaimed “Enough is Enough: Stop Wasting Money on Supplements.” Do you think these studies proved that supplements are a waste of money, or bad for you? For women, for people under the age of 65, and for those who choose to take high quality multivitamins, these studies don’t prove much of anything. They certainly don’t justify the headlines we’ve been seeing.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • YouTube

Disclaimer

The information and contents contained in this Web site has not been evaluated by the FDA. Products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, intend to become pregnant, or nursing, please consult a physician before taking any dietary supplement. If taking prescription drugs, consult your healthcare practitioner prior to use. You must be 18 years or older to purchase products. Individual results do vary.         

About The PMS Comfort Blog

The PMS Comfort Blog is our informal way of keeping you up to date on women’s health issues that we think are important; timely; underappreciated; useful; or just interesting. And, we’ll admit, sometimes we can’t resist poking some good-natured fun at the way the mainstream media portrays health, natural health, and women’s health issues. As always, we’d love to hear from you and are interested in knowing what you think and feel about these or other topics. Leave a comment for us, we’ll always respond. And, if there’s a women’s health topic that’s of interest to you, or that you find confusing, let us know! We want this blog to be helpful to you.

 

Dr. Daniel Heller is the primary author of this blog, the developer of our PMS Natural Relief Programs, and the founder of www.pmscomfort.com. He is a holistic naturopathic doctor in Northern California with over 16 years experience helping thousands of women recover from PMS, PMDD, as well as helping women, children, and families find natural answers to all manner of health challenges.

 

PMS Comfort is here to support you with detailed, practical knowledge presented in a balanced manner you can trust. We are committed to educating, informing, and empowering womenregarding PMS, PMDD, and women’s health, and to providing natural relief for premenstrual symptoms.

 

 

Keep In Touch

We hope you find the PMS Comfort Blog worth keeping track of! You can follow us by Feedsubscribing to this blog. We also have an informative e-newsletter that keeps you abreast of what we've been working on. If you haven't done taken it already, our site's most popular and unique feature is our PMS & PMDD symptom quiz, which has been invaluable for thousands of women in helping them to understand their premenstrual symptoms. If you've enjoyed a post here, we'd appreciate it if you give us a Facebook "Like" or Tweet a link. And, of course, we'd love to have you friend us Facebook, or follow us on Twitter: those links are at the top of the page. Thanks!